Derek O’Brien has criticised the government several times in Parliament. But this time, he was suspended by the Chair. This is what happened...
Category
🗞
NewsTranscript
00:00How can you be doing this, sir? There's no, there's nothing left.
00:03Where have I got time as a member of this house to pass, to put my,
00:10to give you a resolution to send this bill to a select committee?
00:14This is not just the fault of the chair, or the secretary general, or the table office.
00:20This is not just the fault of the entire Sadan, it is the fault of the entire country.
00:30Again, like the farm bills, mockery is being made of Parliament.
00:47That's why we have to come outside to our mobile phone to get this message out to you.
00:53This is worse than the emergency. This is worse than anything else.
01:00This is worse than the emergency. This is worse than anything else.
01:08This is worse than anything else. This is worse than anything else.
01:20It's not a matter of fighting, I'll give you a point of order.
01:23No, no, why will there be a fight?
01:25Sir, one minute, sir, I'm just giving you the rule number.
01:28Please, please, let him give.
01:29Sir, rule number, seriously, sir.
01:32One second.
01:33First, I always like to give you the page number.
01:35Yes, please.
01:36Then it becomes easy for you and for me, sir.
01:38No, I'm saying English copy, no problem.
01:40Okay, 26.
01:41Twenty?
01:42Page number 26.
01:44Right.
01:45Rule number 69.
01:47Yes.
01:48Sir, I'm on a point of order on this listing now, which you want to take up for consideration.
01:55Sir, look at this. 69, subsection 4.
02:02Sir, there is one point of record.
02:04Yesterday, this bill was passed in Lok Sabha at 3 or 4 o'clock.
02:11Sir, this is 3 or 4 o'clock or before that.
02:15And what he is saying here,
02:46No, no, no, no problem.
02:47There's no problem.
02:48Please.
02:49So, have been available for two days before the day on which the motion is made and such
02:58objection shall prevail unless the chairman, I'm reading that, unless the chairman allows
03:06the motion to be made.
03:08So, sir, the residual power lies with that chairman.
03:13If a bill is passed in the Lok Sabha yesterday at 3 p.m., our right as a Rajya Sabha MP is
03:21to bring a select committee resolution, let's say.
03:24Sir, where is the time provided?
03:28Where is the time provided?
03:30Sir, let us look at rule 123.
03:32Yes, come to rule 123.
03:34Sir, this will be on page 41.
03:38Where have I got time as a member of this house to pass, to put my, to give you a resolution
03:47to send this bill to a select committee?
03:49How can you be doing this, sir?
03:51There's no, there's nothing left.
03:53There's no, there's nothing left.
04:23There's nothing left.