Whether craving a plant-based option or a nostalgic bite, this ranking of fish stick brands highlights the crispiest, crunchiest, most delicious ocean treats you can find.
Category
🛠️
LifestyleTranscript
00:00Whether craving a plant-based option or a nostalgic bite, this ranking of fish stick
00:04brands highlights the crispiest, crunchiest, most delicious ocean treats you can find.
00:10Aldi offers its own fish sticks under the Fremont Fish Market brand, alongside a variety
00:15of affordable staples. However, these fish sticks don't always impress. While some customers
00:20enjoy the mild flavor, especially when paired with Aldi's tartar sauce, others are disappointed
00:25by soggy texture and inconsistent breading.
00:28More concerning, a few shoppers have found black meat inside, which is a red flag. Fish
00:32sticks should be white and uniform in color, with no dark spots. This inconsistency raises
00:37doubts about the quality and freshness of the product, making it a less reliable choice
00:41for many.
00:42"'Scuse me."
00:43Considering all factors, it's probably best to skip these and leave them in the freezer
00:47aisle.
00:48Dr. Prager's offers a line of plant-based frozen foods, including their lightly breaded
00:52fish sticks. While not the top contender in the market, they do have some redeeming qualities.
00:58Many customers appreciate the balanced fish-to-breading ratio and the crispy, crunchy coating. However,
01:03they fall short in several areas. The flavor leans a bit too fishy, which is surprising
01:07given that they use mild-tasting pollock. Additionally, the sticks are on the smaller
01:11side.
01:12What makes these shortcomings more frustrating is the higher price tag compared to other
01:15readily available options that offer better taste and value. Ultimately, these fish sticks
01:20may leave you wanting more.
01:22It's great when a brand offers gluten-free alternatives to popular foods, but getting
01:26it right can be challenging. Ian's Foods has made an attempt with their gluten-free
01:30fish sticks, but the outcome leaves much to be desired. Reviews frequently mention the
01:34rubbery, overly chewy texture, which doesn't do justice to the fish inside. Additionally,
01:39the amount of fish in each stick is minimal, and the cornflour-based breading is often
01:43described as too dense. On the positive side, the flavor is fairly mild and not overly salty,
01:49which makes for a welcome change from some other high-sodium options.
01:52However, given the texture issues and the relatively high price for what you get, it's
01:56likely better to try another brand if you're looking for a more satisfying fish stick experience.
02:02Pacific Sustainable Seafood offers gluten-free breaded fish sticks that stand out from many
02:06others on the market. Customers appreciate their impressive size and juiciness, with
02:11these sticks being significantly larger than many alternatives. They're also praised for
02:15their versatility, making them a great addition to various meals. However, their ranking doesn't
02:20reflect these positives fully. While they hold a solid 4.8 out of 5 rating on Amazon,
02:25that score is based on just three reviews. This limited feedback makes it hard to confidently
02:29place them higher in the rankings. Still, if you're open to trying new gluten-free options,
02:34they may be worth testing out for yourself.
02:37KidFresh Frozen Fish Sticks feature a distinctive whole-grain chickpea breading, but they aren't
02:42gluten-free since they still contain wheat flour. This unique breading sets them apart
02:46and has earned praise from customers, particularly for their kid-friendly appeal. Many reviews
02:51highlight how well these fish sticks are received by children, making them a popular choice
02:55for family meals.
02:59While these fish sticks are popular with kids, adults should expect to pay a premium for
03:03them, likely due to the unique breading. They're more expensive than many other options. While
03:07most customers enjoy them, a few negative reviews mention issues like lackluster taste
03:12and freezer burn, so it's worth considering before buying.
03:16For those who don't eat fish but crave the flavors of the sea, plant-based fish sticks
03:19are a game-changer. Gardein's Plant-Based Fish Filets offer a solid alternative, earning
03:24a 4.6 out of 5 rating on Amazon from nearly 5,000 reviews. Customers love how well these
03:30filets mimic real fish, with a convincing flaky texture, light breading, and just the
03:35right amount of fishy flavor. They're a popular choice for those seeking meat-free alternatives,
03:40so why aren't they ranked higher? The issue lies in their shape.
03:43Unlike traditional fish sticks, these filets are triangular, which might not evoke the
03:47same nostalgic feeling for some. This can also make them harder to fit into sandwiches,
03:51which is a minor drawback for some. However, if the shape doesn't bother you, Gardein's
03:55Plant-Based option is a fantastic choice for those looking for a tasty and convincing fish
04:00alternative, offering the same crispy, satisfying experience without any fish involved.
04:06If you're searching for a plant-based fish stick that closely mimics the real deal, GoodCatch
04:10is a top choice. Specializing in plant-based seafood, this brand has nailed the look, texture,
04:16and flavor of traditional fish sticks. Customers rave about how closely they resemble actual
04:20fish, with many praising their crispiness when cooked in an air fryer. That said, there
04:25are a couple of things to note. Some people find the flavor a little too fishy, which
04:28may be surprising given that they're made from plants. Additionally, they might not
04:32crisp up as well if cooked by methods other than air frying.
04:35Despite these minor issues, GoodCatch remains one of the best options for anyone craving
04:39a plant-based alternative to classic fish sticks.
04:42So dip those fish-free fish sticks, but leave the real fish in the sea."
04:46A common complaint about fish sticks is their small size, but Starfish's Gluten-Free Panko-Breaded
04:52Fish Sticks don't have that issue. Coated with corn-flour-based panko breadcrumbs, these
04:56sticks are consistently praised for their generous size and satisfying filling portions.
05:01Customers also love their crispy texture, even without gluten, and their rich, tasty
05:06flavor. However, the larger size isn't for everyone. Some customers find it inconvenient
05:10that the box contains only five to seven sticks, especially considering the higher price point
05:15due to their gluten-free ingredients.
05:17Despite these minor drawbacks, Starfish's fish sticks remain one of the best gluten-free
05:22options available. They offer an exceptional balance of size, taste, and texture, making
05:26them a top choice for those looking for a high-quality, gluten-free alternative.
05:31Trident has earned its reputation as a go-to for quality fish sticks, and for good reason.
05:36With decades of experience fishing off Alaska's shores since the 1970s, the company has honed
05:41its craft, offering a reliable option in the Ultimate Fish Stick. Made with wild Alaska
05:46pollock, these fish sticks feature a crispy, golden coating and a mild, non-overpowering
05:52flavor.
05:53Customers appreciate the light batter and the fact that they're made with sustainable
05:56seafood, giving them a solid environmental appeal. These fish sticks are also incredibly
06:00versatile, making them perfect for fish tacos, paired with rice and tzatziki, or enjoyed
06:05with classic french fries. A standout feature is that they're microwavable, which is a nice
06:10convenience for a traditionally oven-baked or deep-fried snack.
06:13Whether you're looking for an easy meal or a quick snack, Trident's Ultimate Fish Stick
06:17delivers consistent, tasty results that won't disappoint.
06:20So everyone can enjoy the many types of seafood we have to offer.
06:25What makes a great fish stick isn't just the fish itself, but the perfect balance between
06:29the tender, flavorful fish and a crunchy, crispy coating.
06:32Vandekamp's fish sticks stand out in this regard, delivering a satisfying crunch thanks
06:37to a generous wheat-based breading. This crispy exterior gives way to moist, wild-caught fish,
06:42providing that ideal contrast between texture and flavor.
06:46Aesthetically, these sticks are also a win. Customers love the consistent golden-brown
06:50color, avoiding the dull, grayish look that can plague lesser options. With options for
06:55packs of 18, 44, or 60, they're perfect for both small meals or larger gatherings.
07:01While the use of minced fish rather than whole fillets means they don't quite reach the top
07:04of the list, they remain a solid choice for anyone looking for a reliable, tasty fish
07:09stick.
07:10As one Amazon reviewer put it,
07:11"...these sticks are simply deliciously perfect. These fish sticks are an absolute treat. When
07:16I ordered them for my husband, his eyes lit up with the fond memories of his childhood.
07:20The taste is consistent, the quality is top-notch, and the golden, crispy crust paired with tender
07:25fish inside is just as he remembered."
07:28"'This is Vandekamp's for me!"
07:30Gorton's is a trusted name in seafood, and its crunchy breaded fish sticks live up to
07:34the hype. These fish sticks strike an excellent balance between quality and affordability.
07:39Unlike some competitors that offer dry or bland fish, Gorton's sticks feature tender,
07:44flavorful fish that remains juicy after cooking. What sets them apart is their seasoning. These
07:49sticks are generously seasoned, so you don't need to add any extra flavoring. They're versatile,
07:53too, pairing well with just about any side dish. Plus, they're a hit with kids, even
07:58picky eaters, making them a great option for family meals. Whether you're serving them
08:02with fries, veggies, or even in tacos, Gorton's fish sticks provide a tasty, convenient choice.
08:09Mrs. Paul's crunchy breaded fish sticks earn the runner-up spot for good reason. They're
08:13the epitome of comfort food, delivering that nostalgic taste we all remember from childhood.
08:18Each fish stick is perfectly coated in a batter that crisps up beautifully without
08:22turning to mush, offering that satisfying crunch you crave. And it's not just adults
08:26who will love them. Numerous positive reviews highlight how much kids enjoy these fish sticks,
08:31making them a family favorite. The fish itself is mild with a subtle taste and a minimal
08:35odor, making it easy to enjoy without any overpowering fishiness. Plus, they're affordable,
08:41often cheaper than many other options on the market, yet still deliver great taste and
08:45Given that even some lower-quality fish sticks can cost more, Mrs. Paul's offers a fantastic
08:50value without compromising on flavor or quality. If you're after a reliable, tasty, and budget-friendly
08:56option, these fish sticks are hard to beat.
08:58♪ Mrs. Paul's makes them, cause you've got plenty to do. ♪
09:06The top spot goes to a fish stick that's both affordable and utterly satisfying, 365 by
09:11Whole Foods Market Breaded Fish Sticks. They're not a high-end gourmet item, but rather an
09:16everyday option that consistently delivers in both flavor and value. With an impressive
09:214.5-star rating from over 2,400 reviews on Amazon, these fish sticks are clearly a customer
09:26favorite. What makes them stand out? For one, they have a fantastic, authentic fish flavor
09:31and a crispy, perfectly seasoned coating. Reviewers rave about their great taste and
09:36how they're a hit even with the pickiest eaters. Easy to cook and highly versatile, these fish
09:40sticks are perfect for any meal, whether it's lunch, dinner, or a quick snack. The
09:44best part? The price. Not only are these fish sticks delicious, but they also come in generous
09:49bags with dozens of pieces, making them a great value. No need for frequent trips to
09:53the store, 365's fish sticks will keep you stocked and satisfied without breaking the
09:58bank.