Imaginez que vous soyez confronté à un choix déchirant : vous ne pouvez sauver qu'une seule personne, mais qui ? Explorez avec nous cet intense dilemme éthique et étudions ensemble les facteurs complexes qui influencent nos décisions. Ce scénario très épineux mettra vos valeurs morales au défi et vous fera réfléchir à ce qui compte vraiment pour vous. Nous vous invitons à partager vos pensées et solutions dans les commentaires. Plongeons dans les profondeurs de la réflexion morale ! Animation créée par Sympa.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Musique par Epidemic Sound https://www.epidemicsound.com
Pour ne rien perdre de Sympa, abonnez-vous!: https://goo.gl/6E4Xna
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Nos réseaux sociaux :
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/sympasympacom/
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/sympa.officiel/
Stock de fichiers (photos, vidéos et autres):
https://www.depositphotos.com
https://www.shutterstock.com
https://www.eastnews.ru
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Si tu en veux encore plus, fais un tour ici:
http://sympa-sympa.com
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Musique par Epidemic Sound https://www.epidemicsound.com
Pour ne rien perdre de Sympa, abonnez-vous!: https://goo.gl/6E4Xna
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Nos réseaux sociaux :
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/sympasympacom/
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/sympa.officiel/
Stock de fichiers (photos, vidéos et autres):
https://www.depositphotos.com
https://www.shutterstock.com
https://www.eastnews.ru
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Si tu en veux encore plus, fais un tour ici:
http://sympa-sympa.com
Category
😹
FunTranscript
00:00A ship crosses the Atlantic Ocean when a storm breaks out.
00:04At first, the situation does not seem very serious,
00:07but soon, the passengers of the ship realize that things are getting worse.
00:11The waves are huge, and nothing can save the ship.
00:15It's starting to sink.
00:17On board, there is only one lifeboat.
00:20And unfortunately, it can only carry one person.
00:23The captain is in a terrible situation.
00:25He has to decide which passenger will be given a chance to survive.
00:29In addition to the captain, there are eight people on board.
00:32Some of them seem nice,
00:34others mean,
00:35but it's impossible to really get to the bottom of things before it's too late.
00:40The first passenger is Alex,
00:42a 28-year-old talented artist.
00:44He has just had his first international exhibition,
00:47and is doing very well.
00:49He says he wants to inspire the world with his art,
00:52but in reality,
00:53it's his shy twin brother who painted his masterpieces,
00:56and Alex only wants to steal the star from him.
00:59The next passenger is Maria.
01:01She is 23 years old, and she is 8 months pregnant.
01:04She is capricious, often behaves irrationally,
01:08and treats the staff rather badly.
01:10She travels to go back to her husband,
01:12but what he does not know is that the child is not his,
01:15but his best friend's.
01:17She has been cheating on him forever.
01:19However, we cannot let this innocent soul perish, can we?
01:24Despite his neglected appearance,
01:26this 65-year-old scientist,
01:28Professor Marcus,
01:30is an eminent researcher in the field of genetic therapy.
01:33He is working on a project that could save millions of lives,
01:36but he also has some skeletons in his closet.
01:40It's been 15 years since anyone has seen his wife, Judith.
01:44Does Marcus' scientific progress have anything to do with his mysterious disappearance?
01:50Dr. Anna is 34 years old.
01:52She is a surgeon, and has saved hundreds of lives in natural disasters.
01:56She is successful as a doctor,
01:59but she is not a very good mother.
02:01Her three daughters live with their father,
02:03and do not want to know anything about her.
02:06Teresa, aged 78, is a widow,
02:09and her family abandoned her because of her bad temper.
02:12She travels for the last time in her life
02:14to visit the grave of her late husband.
02:18There is also Mark, who is only 7 years old.
02:20His indisciplined character has caused a lot of disputes among passengers.
02:24He travels alone.
02:26His parents must find him at the arrival.
02:28The parents of this little monster are too busy working.
02:32So he is more and more uncontrollable.
02:34Who knows what he will be able to do in ten years?
02:40An android robot, Alpha 3, is also on board the ship.
02:44It is a very useful artificial intelligence during expeditions.
02:48It can also control the ship in case of emergency.
02:53And the last passenger is Emily.
02:55This 30-year-old woman is beautiful and charming.
02:59She takes advantage of old rich and powerful men,
03:01and has a lot of money.
03:03She has not worked a single day of her life,
03:05and was born on this ship only for the pleasure of the trip.
03:08To make her choice,
03:09the captain invites each of the passengers to tell their story.
03:14He asks them one question.
03:16Why should you be the one who survives?
03:20Alex replies.
03:22You see, my art can inspire and change the world.
03:25By looking at my works, people discover the beauty of life.
03:29A great help in difficult times.
03:31I must survive.
03:33I have so much to give to the world with my paintings.
03:36Maria replies.
03:38Don't you see that a new life is growing in me?
03:41My child and I must survive.
03:44This child could become an artist or an important scientist.
03:48It is not only about my life.
03:52Professor Marcus says.
03:54My work is not finished yet.
03:57It could save thousands of lives.
03:59I am close to a major breakthrough,
04:01and I must survive to achieve it.
04:03Dr. Anna declares.
04:05My hands save lives.
04:06I have proven many times that I can achieve the impossible in extreme conditions.
04:10The world cannot afford to lose my skills and my knowledge.
04:15The old woman begs.
04:18Please, you must understand me.
04:21I may have lived a long time, but I want to see my husband's grave.
04:26Mark says.
04:27I am still a child.
04:29My parents are waiting for me at home.
04:31I want to hold my mom and dad in my arms.
04:34Alpha 3 declares that it was created to serve and help people.
04:38Its ability to analyze situations and make rational decisions in the event of a crisis
04:43can be used to prevent future disasters.
04:47Emily declares.
04:48Look at me.
04:49Doesn't everyone have their own unique value?
04:52I am young and beautiful, and I have a lot of potential.
04:55You can see that, can't you?
04:58The captain is desperate.
05:01How can a mere mortal decide who must live and who must perish?
05:06After making the 100 steps in his cabin and hitting the walls with his fists,
05:10he decides to...
05:13evaluate the passengers according to their utility.
05:17Alex, as a talented artist, can influence society through his art
05:23and inspire thousands of people with his masterpieces.
05:26But who knows how far his vanity can lead him?
05:29Besides, remember that he is not the real artist.
05:34Saving Maria is also saving his child.
05:37But as cynical as it may seem,
05:39the contribution of these two beings to future society is only hypothetical.
05:44What if this child grew up to become a criminal?
05:48Professor Marcus can indeed bring significant benefits to society
05:53thanks to his scientific research.
05:55But he is not young.
05:57And if he did not live long enough to finish his work?
06:01Dr. Anna is a surgeon.
06:03She has already saved many lives and will certainly continue to do so in the future.
06:09Her ability to provide immediate medical assistance in critical situations
06:13makes her one of the best candidates for survival
06:16because she can save lives directly and regularly.
06:21At the same time, she is a bad mother
06:23and the influence she can have on the lives of her daughters can be harmful.
06:28Teresa is a living witness to history and human experience.
06:32But unfortunately, her ability to contribute to society is limited by time.
06:37In simple terms, she is old
06:39and we cannot know how much time she has left.
06:43Marcus is in a similar situation.
06:46He has a long and potentially productive life ahead of him.
06:49But his immediate contribution to society is limited.
06:53His value rests only on his future contribution,
06:56which is difficult to estimate at the moment.
07:00Alpha 3 can provide valuable technical assistance and functional support.
07:04But as a robot, it brings nothing direct to human well-being.
07:10As for Emily, despite her beauty, her achievements are minimal.
07:14On the other hand, she only frequents rich and powerful people.
07:19So she has a lot of influence on society.
07:23Now, from the point of view of the benefits that each passenger can bring,
07:27it would seem that Dr. Anna is one of the most logical choices.
07:31His knowledge and skills can save many lives,
07:35which means the greatest good for the greatest number.
07:39But let's examine the captain's choice.
07:41After all, after listening to all the passengers and rushing through time,
07:47our man decides to save Emily.
07:50Can you guess why he made such an unexpected choice?
07:53Write your answer in the comments.
07:55You can also pause the video to think about it.
08:00Well, I think you are ready for the answer.
08:03Do you see?
08:04Although each of the passengers presented very convincing arguments
08:08to explain why he had to be saved,
08:10the captain was particularly touched by Emily's charm.
08:14And even if there were more logical candidates in terms of utility and humanism,
08:19the captain succumbed to his personal feelings and preferences,
08:23which influenced his decision.
08:26This puzzle illustrates that in reality,
08:28people often focus on their sympathy and preferences
08:31rather than on logic or public interest to make decisions.
08:35This is due to the fact that emotions and personal relationships
08:38can have a strong influence on our perception of situations and our choices.
08:43Here is a concrete example.
08:44Human resources managers tend to choose candidates they appreciate
08:49or with whom they share common interests.
08:52And it does not matter that other candidates
08:54may have skills or a more suitable experience.
08:57This phenomenon is known as the effect of similarity.
09:00Now, I have an important question for you.
09:02Which passenger would you save?
09:05Share your choice in the comments.
09:07But I would like to remind you that there is no correct answer.