புதுசா கார் வாங்கப்போறீங்களா? மேனுவல் கியர் ஆப்ஷன் பெஸ்டா? ஆட்டோமெட்டிக் கியர் பெஸ்டா?
~PR.306~PR.156~CA.174~ED.70~##~
~PR.306~PR.156~CA.174~ED.70~##~
Category
🗞
NewsTranscript
00:00So guys, today's debate is about manual or automatic gearbest
00:05I am Palvin and he is Giri Mani
00:08So let's get into the video
00:10So Giri, when we look at the overall sales
00:15In the US, 3% of manual cars are sold
00:19But in Asia and Europe, 85% of manual cars are sold
00:26According to Google reports
00:28I am saying that manual cars are the best
00:32I have an answer to your question
00:35You said that in the US, 3% of manual cars are sold
00:39So no matter what the advancement is, it comes from there
00:43So R&D happens from there
00:45Plus, the second half of the question you asked is
00:48In Europe and Asia, manual cars are sold more
00:52Leave it in Asia, I am coming to the Indian mindset
00:56For example, in the Indian mindset
00:58If you buy a vehicle
01:00The first priority is the budget
01:02Then comes the mileage
01:04And then the next features
01:06So when it comes to the budget
01:08Obviously, the automatic is a bit
01:10Since it has additional technology
01:12There is additional investment
01:14So the price will be a bit high
01:16So if we go to the base variant
01:18It will come in manual
01:20That's why manual cars are sold more
01:22But it is not a stand-by
01:25Now they are slowly adapting
01:27Towards the new technology
01:29Because in India, there is a lot of traffic
01:31So manual driving is stressful
01:35There is frequent shifting stress
01:37But we drive happily
01:39We put the gear
01:41Then drive or neutral
01:43We drive stress-free
01:45So when you say
01:47Since you have an automatic
01:49You drive stress-free
01:51But I
01:53If I drive manual
01:55It feels like driving a Getta
01:57Because I am driving in a stylish place
01:59If there is a traffic
02:01If I have to stop a vehicle
02:03I will automatically shift gears
02:05With a bass voice
02:07In a stylish way
02:09If you do this automatically
02:11Automatically the gear
02:13According to the RPM
02:15It will automatically choose the gear
02:17So I
02:19Personally
02:21I don't want the crowd to see me
02:23So when I do that
02:25Everyone will see me
02:27Another thing is
02:29It is a different feel
02:31When you do it for real
02:33You will get a goosebump moment
02:35Ok Parvin, I accept what you said
02:37So what Parvin is saying is
02:39A goosebump moment
02:41Road presence
02:43Attention-seeking moments
02:45You can do it manually
02:47But you can't do it frequently
02:50So this is like an occasion
02:52So for example
02:54If you go for a trucking
02:56It is an occasional
02:58But if you do it frequently
03:00You will get fed up
03:02So attention-seeking
03:04And doing small stunts
03:06It is a moment of the time
03:08To enjoy the moment
03:10But this kind of fun
03:12We will get it automatically
03:14For example
03:16I said stress-free
03:18But the attention-seeking
03:20Will be there
03:22Because the attention-seeking
03:24Will be outside
03:26But the attention-seeking
03:28Will be inside
03:30So the manual gearbox
03:32Will be the same
03:34But the automatic
03:36Will be in different variants
03:38We take attention-seeking
03:40In the interior
03:42I am saying
03:44It is not just for the outer
03:46If you drive
03:48The driver will feel it
03:50I am saying
03:52The attention-seeking and the pressure
03:54Will be there
03:56For the drivers
03:58And the people around
04:00The feel will be there
04:02Another thing
04:04For example
04:06I am moving
04:08When I do a full rev
04:10I can feel the adrenal
04:12I shift gears
04:15When I shift
04:17I can feel
04:19The G-Force
04:21Pulling the car
04:23I am saying
04:25You will get that feel in the manual
04:27So what he is saying
04:29He is saying
04:31He is getting the pressure
04:33When doing overtaking
04:35Or instant torque
04:37When you do a manual
04:39You will get a personal feel
04:41But we are not saying
04:43When you shift gears
04:45When you do an aggressive torque
04:47Two gears will automatically down
04:49We are not putting any physical stress
04:51But still we get the same fun
04:53But I agree
04:55If you get 100% fun
04:57We will get 99%
04:59Because we are going towards the technology
05:01So when you say technology
05:03You are talking about
05:05My point of view
05:07So
05:09It is a bit boring
05:11So in manual
05:13Each and every second
05:15I am in control
05:17Everything is under my control
05:19For example
05:21If someone comes
05:23I shift gears
05:25I can use the engine braking
05:27When I apply the brake
05:29My braking is also more
05:31Other than that
05:33Performance wise
05:35I use sequential gear shifter
05:37Just pull it
05:39Pull up
05:41So
05:43Even I feel
05:45Stress relaxed
05:47For example
05:49Big cars
05:51Drift cars
05:53For example
05:55I can drift wherever I want
05:57Because in manual car
05:59There is a handbrake
06:01In automatic car, there is no handbrake
06:03So it is like an e-brake
06:05But when we do a turn
06:08The torque will release
06:10Handbrake and steering
06:12Control
06:14Release the handbrake
06:16Press the throttle
06:18The car will drift
06:20But can you do this?
06:22So in what you said
06:24If there is an unexpected incident
06:26I will use the engine braking
06:28In lower shift
06:30Plus I will use the brake
06:32So for that
06:34I will answer you
06:36In absence of mind
06:38There will be humanly errors
06:40In absence of mind
06:42You will use engine braking
06:44If you don't know about engine braking
06:46In manual
06:48If you brake immediately
06:50The car will stall
06:52But in automatic
06:54Even if there is an absence of mind
06:56Just apply the brake
06:58Gear shifting will happen
07:00The car will stand still
07:02Even if it is an object
07:04There will be no effect
07:06So in absence of mind
07:08There is no need to use physical input
07:10If you use handbrake
07:12The gearbox will be damaged
07:14There are multiple chances
07:16So next time
07:18Not on roads
07:20Because he was talking about drifting
07:22So don't try stunts on roads
07:24But because he has a race track
07:26He is bringing it here
07:28So this is only for track purpose
07:30So like you said
07:33If you are having fun
07:35We are also having fun
07:37Because you are using handbrake
07:39Default in A, B, C
07:41If we use left leg
07:43In drift time
07:45We apply the brake
07:47But we are using leg brake
07:49Still we get the drift feel
07:51If you get this much accuracy
07:53You won't get
07:55But still we are having that fun
07:57So you talked about engine
07:59Like life
08:01In manual gear
08:03I can take mileage
08:07In manual gear
08:09For every speed
08:11I can feel
08:13Properly
08:15If the engine is not stressed
08:19If I can go in 3rd gear
08:21I can drive at this speed
08:23But in automatic gear it won't happen
08:25The gear shifts automatically
08:27So in this
08:29In top gear
08:31I can feel the engine
08:33But you can't feel the engine
08:35Sorry
08:37Engine braking
08:39So in that
08:41In manual gear
08:43You will put more stress
08:45In manual gear
08:47You have to put more physical effort
08:49Like you said
08:51What I do is
08:53Because I put physical effort
08:55I can feel
08:58I can judge
09:00Automatically it won't happen
09:02That's my opinion
09:04Like you said
09:06The RPM
09:08Indirectly
09:10The speed
09:12I can manage
09:14I have full control manual
09:16But
09:18In everything
09:20You say non
09:22But in manual gear
09:24You can't
09:26There are beginners
09:28Intermediates
09:30Advanced drivers
09:32When we go as a common public
09:34Many people are manual and automatic
09:36They don't know about RPM
09:38So in that time
09:40If we talk about general public
09:42It will be stressful
09:44Many people don't know
09:46In which speed or RPM
09:48They do it earlier
09:50Some do it in average
09:52Some do it badly
09:54Some do it in lower gear
09:56They have that resistance
09:58This resistance
10:00Is the main reason
10:02In an expensive car
10:04Automatic gearbox
10:06In low end variant
10:08This is one of the factors
10:10So demand
10:12What is the demand
10:14Manufacturers provide
10:16I am not saying
10:18There is no fun in manual
10:20I am saying
10:22So he is saying
10:24There is fun in automatic
10:26But in manual
10:28There is no fun
10:30I am saying it frankly
10:32There is no fun in manual
10:34I have a manual
10:36But still
10:38I am saying
10:40We have a vision
10:42We are trying to utilize
10:44The technology advancement
10:46How convenient it is
10:48If you say manual is best
10:51But manual is much more fun
10:53Fun to drive
10:55In some scenarios
10:57I will do it
10:59There are many advantages
11:01That's why I am here
11:03So yeah
11:05Another advantage
11:07Mileage
11:09Normal cars
11:11Many people take manual
11:13Or automatic
11:15Fuel is important for everyone
11:17Today petrol prices
11:19Increasing
11:21Time is less
11:23But increasing
11:25Mileage
11:27I have seen
11:29Manual gear gives more mileage
11:31In the beginning of this video
11:33I said
11:35First is budget
11:37Second is mileage
11:39We haven't reached there yet
11:41But we are going towards
11:43The technology advancement
11:45In manual
11:47Because of gear shifting
11:49And who drives it
11:51But recently
11:53Maruti launched a new shift
11:55In that
11:57In manual, mileage is less
11:59In automatic, mileage is more
12:01I can't show my face here
12:03But Maruti did a great job
12:05There is good in manual
12:07And good in automatic
12:09If you are a pro driver
12:11Or a car lover
12:13What you expect
12:16You expect manual
12:18But
12:20If you are a beginner
12:22Or
12:24If you want to shift gears
12:26You have to use clutch
12:28To shift gears
12:30But Maruti
12:32If you want to shift gears
12:34You can choose
12:36What Maruti chose
12:38So
12:40Another point
12:42Our vehicle
12:44Manual has a budget
12:46As you said
12:48But
12:50Nowadays
12:52Some brands bring it in low price
12:54In that area
12:56In the future
12:58I prefer
13:00Manual gear
13:02Lower price
13:04If you want to upgrade
13:06You have to resell
13:08So
13:10Initially
13:12Even if you pay a high price
13:14Even if you pay a high price
13:16In the future
13:18If you want to buy a high end
13:20Performance oriented vehicle
13:22Still
13:24Your resell value is
13:26Additional
13:28Service cost
13:30I would say
13:32Overall service cost is low
13:34But
13:36In automatic
13:38If there is a sensor
13:41The vehicle will be in that area
13:43Yes
13:45If the vehicle is broken
13:47Or
13:49If the battery is low
13:51I will push the button
13:53And start the engine
13:55Automatically
13:57Not in all vehicles
13:59You don't have to open the pin
14:01But
14:03In that area
14:05If there is a high stress
14:07I will shift the gear
14:09I will start the engine
14:11Palvin has a good point
14:13I have an answer for that
14:15You said manual service cost is low
14:17I agree
14:19Automatically
14:21Service cost is high
14:23But
14:25When we use manual
14:27For example
14:29If 4 people use the same vehicle
14:31The driving dynamics will be different
14:33There is a higher chance of getting hit by the gearbox
14:35Even if the service cost is low
14:37The frequency of the service is high
14:39But
14:41Even if the service cost is high
14:43The frequency is high
14:45There is a high chance of getting hit by the gearbox
14:47If 4 people use the same vehicle
14:49Because
14:51The manual control
14:53Is automatic
14:55The control ratio will be the same
14:57So the service cost will be low
14:59You said about towing
15:01For example
15:03I don't want to say the brand name
15:05In safety rating, it is 1 star
15:07But
15:09In the current premium luxury cars
15:11It is one of the best selling
15:13But in safety rating, it is 1
15:15But people buy it
15:17So the brand name is the same
15:19The safety rating you are talking about
15:21If there is an accident
15:23How can we save you?
15:25We promise you
15:27If you drive this vehicle, you will not get into an accident
15:29That kind of promise
15:31So this is possible
15:34You can push the manual
15:36You can push the manual
15:38You can tow
15:40I think we can compromise
15:42For the once in a while
15:44So
15:46You can put it in neutral
15:48You can put it in neutral
15:50You can put it in neutral
15:52It is up to you
15:54Parvin needs manual
15:56I need automatic
15:58So what is your choice?
16:00Tell us in the comment
16:02If you have any hot topic
16:04Hot debate
16:06Or if you need more information
16:08Parvin and I are here
16:10Share it in the comment section
16:12Don't forget to like and share
16:14Subscribe to Tamil Drives Park
16:16See you in another video
16:18Until then stay safe
16:20Drive automatic cars
16:22Drive manual cars
16:24Bye