Daghang mga ahensya sa gobyerno ang daling mogamit sa Data Privacy Act kung adunay mga dokumento nga pangayuon ang mga reporters. Unsa man gyud ang Data Privacy Act.
Atong sayron kang Lt. Col. Gerard Pelare ug Atty. Ian Manticajon unsa ang Data Privacy Act.
Sa lain bahin mahinabi nato karon ang konsehal sa Barangay Punta Engano kalabot sa operasyon sa M.V. Diamond Highway nga gireklamo sa mga residente sa maong lugar.
Ato ning hisgutan karon sa Beyond the Headlines.
#BeyondtheHeadlines
#AllYouNeedToKnow
#DataPrivacyAct
Atong sayron kang Lt. Col. Gerard Pelare ug Atty. Ian Manticajon unsa ang Data Privacy Act.
Sa lain bahin mahinabi nato karon ang konsehal sa Barangay Punta Engano kalabot sa operasyon sa M.V. Diamond Highway nga gireklamo sa mga residente sa maong lugar.
Ato ning hisgutan karon sa Beyond the Headlines.
#BeyondtheHeadlines
#AllYouNeedToKnow
#DataPrivacyAct
Category
🗞
NewsTranscript
00:00 Mayondo, Sugo, Mayondo, Filipinas,
00:03 Kini, beyond the headlines,
00:05 Nintong Iagyag,
00:06 Uyibisto ang mga abuso.
00:08 Atong tabangan,
00:09 Aron ang problema sa Sugo,
00:11 Masolusyonan.
00:12 Uglabaw satanan,
00:13 Atong ipalanog ang tingog sa komunidad.
00:16 Biernes karon,
00:17 Mayo 17, 2024,
00:21 Mayondo, ginuntan,
00:23 Ako si Duno,
00:23 Mayondo day,
00:24 Ako si Duno Moralio.
00:25 Mayondo, ako si Mildred Galarpe,
00:27 Dung biernes na.
00:29 Yes, biernes na.
00:30 Nahumanan nato ang lima kaadlaw
00:31 ng semana ng working days.
00:33 Struggles sa kinabuhi.
00:35 Norin lang kita, no?
00:36 Struggles sa kinabuhi.
00:37 Pusa kasimana na nalabyan nato
00:39 ang mga hakit sa kinabuhi.
00:42 Pero, mga igala,
00:43 Sugad lunis,
00:43 nagsugod atong mga challenges.
00:46 Pero nahumanan nato ang
00:47 katapusang adlaw sa trabaho,
00:49 sa regular work, ha?
00:50 Dilikat kung kaya na may mga
00:52 trabaho nga lain ang adlaw
00:53 sa ilang day, o.
00:54 At nahumanan nato ang,
00:56 nahumanan nato ang semana
00:59 nag-turnout na makapahaway ta
01:01 sa weekend.
01:02 Okay, so,
01:03 sina-out nga makarelax, no?
01:04 Karelax ta,
01:05 spend ta sa atong pamilya,
01:06 spend ta,
01:07 u-uras ta.
01:08 Para mo, gain atong mag-strength
01:09 para for another week of
01:11 struggles sa kinabuhi.
01:12 [Laughs]
01:13 Mangandang takay.
01:15 Nanapuwin lain,
01:16 struggles.
01:17 Struggles and celebrations.
01:19 Pa'o mong ginawa.
01:20 Naatay challenges,
01:21 naaputay mga celebrations,
01:23 mga achievements sa atong kinabuhi.
01:25 So, karo buntaga,
01:26 nindot kaya itong isguta, no?
01:28 Informative niya, mga regala.
01:30 Labi na sa media,
01:32 o gato,
01:34 bisang kanang mga private individuals,
01:36 o gusto mo,
01:37 labi na mo access sa mga
01:39 police documents, no?
01:41 Not just police documents, no,
01:43 but even kanang mga government,
01:45 government data,
01:47 mo ngayo ka,
01:49 naakay muhatag ka,
01:50 o imong personal information ba kaya.
01:52 Karoon raba,
01:54 mga fake news,
01:56 information is gold.
01:58 Data is gold, no?
02:00 Sa kanang kalibutan,
02:02 ang information.
02:04 Hinomdumta,
02:06 nga katong pagsugod na 'to sa SIM registration,
02:08 laghan kay tao,
02:10 mag-receive ng mga notices,
02:12 kaila pa, personal pa.
02:14 "Hi Mildred, would you like to avail of a car loan?"
02:16 "Uy, di ko anang car loan."
02:18 "Car loan, drama."
02:20 Bita, ang isgutan karoon,
02:22 ang Data Privacy Act of 2012.
02:24 Unsa magigdi,
02:26 unsa magigdi ang Data Privacy Act.
02:28 Labina, kaya ang atong kapulisan,
02:30 na sila'y
02:32 kanang protocol,
02:34 protocol,
02:36 kung atong mga
02:38 matrabaho sa media mo ato,
02:40 mga iyong data,
02:42 sila muhatag sa details of it,
02:44 kaya mo, they invoke on data privacy.
02:46 So unsa man isang part.
02:48 Atong pangayuan,
02:50 o kanang explanation,
02:52 si Lt. Col. Gerard Pilaray,
02:54 siya ang spokesperson sa PR07,
02:56 kung unsa ni siya
02:58 bag-uban ni protocol
03:00 or gibalik lang.
03:02 At the same time,
03:04 aside ni Col. Pilaray,
03:06 makauban po nato si Atty. Ayan Mantikahon,
03:08 kauban nato sa buhat,
03:10 unsa ni siya na columnist,
03:12 at the same time,
03:14 professor ni siya sa
03:16 University of the Philippines.
03:18 Para mahatagan taong...
03:20 He's active sa Cebu Citizens Press Council.
03:22 Mahatagan ta niya
03:24 o kanang pagpasabot,
03:26 unsa man ang Data Privacy Act,
03:28 unsa man ang limitations,
03:30 unsa ang restrictions,
03:32 atang sa mga nagtrabaho sa media.
03:34 So unahong nato si...
03:36 Pero before,
03:38 before we mag-serious ta,
03:40 at the same time,
03:42 koan, malimtan, mapikit,
03:44 ato sa ni Igrit,
03:46 ang among master sa among control center,
03:48 ugma pa niyang birthday,
03:50 kaya walang man tayo...
03:52 Beyond the headlines, ugma.
03:54 So among sa Igrit,
03:56 ang master control namo si
03:58 Frank Nel Felipe,
04:00 na nga araw sa Kamotes,
04:02 arang sa iyang
04:04 birthday ugmang adlawa.
04:06 Wak nagigat eh,
04:08 makasamahan nga kang Engineer Frank,
04:10 kaya wak pa ni gawa siyang pinaka-gwapong picture.
04:12 Later, ato ni pakita.
04:14 Amo na si Frank Nel Felipe
04:16 na nga igala siya,
04:18 ang among master control sa among
04:20 tech booth.
04:22 Iyang birthday ugma.
04:24 Laeng mag-birthday ugma ang among reporter
04:26 na akakuhag...
04:28 Among reporter na si Arkin Larisma.
04:30 Siya ni ang nag-cover
04:32 sa City Hall.
04:34 At the same time, runner niya sad.
04:36 Runner?
04:38 Mudagan niya. Athletic niya.
04:40 Super runner.
04:42 Laki ni si Arkin.
04:44 Taas lang na iyang hair.
04:46 Happy birthday ugma daan Arkin Larisma.
04:48 Of course, related to
04:50 happy birthday to Chari Coronel.
04:52 I'm sorry.
04:54 I'm sorry.
04:56 May kagahapon,
04:58 weeklong celebration.
05:00 Beda-beda tamang duge.
05:02 So, naanakaroon sa linea,
05:04 naanakaroon sa Zoom,
05:06 atong ma-interview si
05:08 Lt. Col. General
05:10 General Pilari.
05:12 Pero ganahinapos si Col. Pilari
05:14 ano dong ayin mo siyang, di ba?
05:16 Lt. General, ganahinapos si Col. Pilari
05:18 ano dong.
05:20 Sir, mayayong oto.
05:22 Thank you.
05:24 Mayayong hapon. Thank you sir for promoting me.
05:26 Siyang spokesperson.
05:30 Magbilang angel ka sana para bukas,
05:32 General na si Col. Pilari.
05:34 Ako nag-promote naan sir.
05:36 It's good to be back.
05:40 We are happy for the
05:42 opportunity given to us once again.
05:44 Yes.
05:46 We always want to
05:48 get your explanation kaya I know you are
05:50 a very accessible
05:52 mansag ka to us.
05:54 There seems to be a
05:56 I don't know if it's a confusion
05:58 or we just need to get a clarification
06:00 regarding
06:02 ang ginaimbog
06:04 sa mga police stations
06:06 when reporters asked for
06:08 data on
06:10 crimes committed in their respective
06:12 area of jurisdiction on data
06:14 privacy. So, what is the stand
06:16 or what is the protocol of the police
06:18 on this matter?
06:20 I'd like to start by
06:22 re-emphasizing
06:24 it has always been the position of the
06:26 PNP that media is
06:28 our partner in
06:30 our performance of
06:32 our duty. Ang media
06:34 among gitan awa na usa kaya
06:36 indispensable partner para
06:38 maahinunan
06:40 among duty of providing
06:42 crime solution and crime
06:44 prevention initiative.
06:46 Although
06:48 recently na ay mga
06:50 policy na gipasa
06:52 sa PNP, that is actually
06:54 not new but a reiteration
06:56 of previous
06:58 policies and laws.
07:00 Usaan ikini
07:02 gitawag natong freedom of
07:04 information manual sa PNP.
07:06 Number one, we
07:08 recognize that it is
07:10 the duty of the PNP as the government
07:12 agency na magdisclose
07:14 and mag
07:16 make sure na accessible ang
07:18 information to the public because that is a
07:20 constitutional guarantee actually.
07:22 So, we actually
07:24 recognize that and we reiterate that
07:26 in major policies that we have
07:28 but we also need to consider
07:30 naa apoy mga balaod
07:32 na nag limit sa amo ang
07:34 paghatag o mga
07:36 information. Saan e,
07:38 kini of course, kini rights of the
07:40 accused na naapoy sa
07:42 constitution.
07:44 Of course, kini akong
07:46 freedom of information
07:48 manual na among
07:50 gisunod karoon.
07:52 Actually, recognize that there are
07:54 certain information na
07:56 dilik pa na mo umahatat. For example,
07:58 kini ang mga
08:00 kaso na sa court,
08:02 we call that in law
08:04 as the sub judice
08:06 doctrine. Yes, law of sub judice.
08:08 Pending ang kaso,
08:10 dilik po pwede
08:12 maghatag o information na na. Otherwise,
08:14 that will be contemptuous on our part.
08:16 Kini sa
08:18 data privacy act na atong
08:20 strictly ginasunod karoon
08:22 in respect to
08:24 the privacy of
08:26 individuals. We cannot just give
08:28 in information without the consent
08:30 of the involved
08:32 parties. So,
08:34 ang atong main policy karoon
08:36 na 2023 na amendment
08:38 katunang among gidiseminate.
08:40 Actually, this has been disseminated
08:42 with the media
08:44 na na yung mga bangung mga
08:46 kabaguhan. For example, we cannot name
08:48 suspects anymore.
08:50 We cannot name victims
08:52 or the involved personnel
08:54 in the investigation
08:56 because of data privacy act.
08:58 Then, katong
09:00 sa una ng mga rules
09:02 pertaining to minors,
09:04 of course, we have reiterated it in the
09:06 new policy that we have.
09:08 This is a memorandum circular
09:10 in
09:12 2023 na
09:14 gipasa sa PNP.
09:16 That is what is our
09:18 guide now in
09:20 dealing with the media.
09:22 Ang amo ang gustong
09:24 i-emphasize, no?
09:26 Ang media is always a partner
09:28 of the Philippine National Police.
09:30 We have
09:32 seen a lot of
09:34 improvement in our
09:36 delivery of police services because of
09:38 our partnership sa media.
09:40 We do not intend to
09:42 cut off that relationship.
09:44 Instead, we want to
09:46 flourish it, no?
09:48 Of course, in accord with the procedures
09:50 that we are following.
09:52 Sir, when you said
09:54 na dilit na nato pwede
09:56 manganlan just to protect
09:58 the victims and
10:00 the
10:02 suspects
10:04 of their rights.
10:06 Does that include
10:08 information process for
10:10 journalistic
10:12 outputs?
10:14 Yes.
10:16 Usa na sa mga
10:18 gitan awng avenue
10:20 ng atong
10:22 dili na to marilis
10:24 sa atong media partners
10:26 kini ang mga names
10:28 sa suspects o sa victims,
10:30 that is specified
10:32 in the new
10:34 rules that we are following.
10:36 Rules mag-rilis sa
10:38 PNP? Yes.
10:40 Example, we conduct an investigation
10:42 then we have
10:44 identified witnesses, we have
10:46 identified the victims and the
10:48 suspects. At the moment,
10:50 we are not authorized to
10:52 release this information
10:54 to the media.
10:56 Pursuant to data privacy,
10:58 naman ko po yung usahay,
11:00 makabantay mo nga.
11:02 Manganlan na ang tawa suspect
11:04 but actually they are still presumed
11:06 innocent until proven otherwise.
11:08 Pag imong i-release
11:10 ang ilang names
11:12 from the PNP,
11:14 that could be a violation of their rights
11:16 kay ma-daot na ang ilang
11:18 name, ma-daot na ilang image.
11:20 We are very, very careful
11:22 in dealing with this kind
11:24 of situation.
11:26 Sa tanan ba niyong cases,
11:28 kay there are a lot of cases, mga HINEOS, mga PETI crimes,
11:30 so kani bang dili mag-name
11:32 sa mga victims and suspect
11:34 kaning tanan ba niyong
11:36 klaso from
11:38 PETI crimes to
11:40 mga HINEOS crimes?
11:42 Yes, there was no distinction
11:44 given sa policy nato.
11:46 So, ang tanan kaso
11:48 na ka-identified
11:50 tawag victims and suspects,
11:52 dili pa may be authorized nga mo
11:54 release
11:56 sa atong ninja partners.
11:58 Pero sir, kaning
12:00 if the information or the names,
12:02 URL names is not coming from your
12:04 end, probably kaning sa
12:06 reporter lang akoan, is that
12:08 a violation sa inyong gan or okay lang na siya?
12:10 Well, there's no problem if
12:12 the reporter can
12:14 get it from other sources.
12:16 But,
12:18 what is...
12:20 If the
12:22 information is
12:24 actually released officially by the
12:26 PMP. Sir, this includes
12:28 photos or pictures
12:30 sa mga kuhan? Yes.
12:32 Kaning photos,
12:34 dugay naman na siyang
12:36 i-bawal, makabantayin mo,
12:38 naka-blurred na naman mong pictures.
12:40 This is,
12:42 of course, due
12:44 to our observance of
12:46 the presumption of innocence,
12:48 nana-agad sa constitution.
12:50 Yes. So, actually,
12:52 kami sa dugay naman sa media po,
12:54 kaning nag-follow in me kaning
12:56 mga minors or women
12:58 victims, or kaning
13:00 even kaning suspect, di namwingan lan
13:02 pastang ma-relate,
13:04 ma-ilhan kaning, identifiable
13:06 sa ilang family.
13:08 Especially if naging of o kaning familia.
13:10 Yes. Nagkuan nga nga
13:12 discretion, pero kami lang karoon,
13:14 naman gawin mga reaction sa mga news
13:16 nga, "Noon sa mga balita ninyo karoon?"
13:18 Murakonong chismis?
13:20 Murakonong chismis nalang.
13:22 Assertin nilo
13:24 the suspect,
13:26 assertin nilo kuan
13:28 nang gitulog.
13:30 Murah na
13:32 ang mong gawa ang information,
13:34 murah na ang...
13:36 Actually, we instruct,
13:38 we know that coming from me
13:40 hindi pwede, pero we always
13:42 usayang magulisun, magul kayang
13:44 hitapoto asa layo,
13:46 we cannot contact directly to the family
13:48 nga you can get the information
13:50 direct from the victim or the family
13:52 themselves, na we can get their names
13:54 or what other information nga pwede
13:56 natung paggawa. Kami sa Janice Paper, actually,
13:58 for any media outlet, we have
14:00 certain limitations
14:02 unsa ang pagkuan. Labi na karoon nga
14:04 nakuantah, narahat sa Facebook,
14:06 online, grabe muha muha, tag natu rin,
14:08 di ina tayong tumakita pila
14:10 kadalaw. So, dagan sa dimingi bantayan.
14:12 Pero kini, very surprising
14:14 because for so long,
14:16 we know that, kanin blatter
14:18 is a public document.
14:20 So, supposedly accessible to the public,
14:22 whoever wants to kuhan muha ito. Pero
14:24 with this kuhan, Privacy
14:26 Act, nga ipalo,
14:28 na di di na ni ma-public
14:30 document atong kuhan, blatter,
14:32 nga ni. Nothing
14:34 strange, still.
14:36 The blatter
14:38 as far as
14:40 judicial
14:42 concepts are concerned,
14:44 it is still a
14:46 public document. Ang nabaguna
14:48 lang is kung kano sa amin
14:50 pwede mo hatag sa
14:52 information and what information
14:54 to give. Wala may laing
14:56 nabago. We can narrate the incident,
14:58 what really happened, but what
15:00 we just are trying to
15:02 withdraw now are
15:04 actual names. Kung inundun mo sa
15:06 minors, di man pwede gyan i-
15:08 storya. The same concept,
15:10 because not until
15:12 they are convicted in court,
15:14 that's the time that we can say that
15:16 kungan din sila, sila gigihimo
15:18 sa crime. But before
15:20 that, they are still
15:22 suspects and they are afforded with that right.
15:24 Pero di bagay na
15:26 sir, ang
15:28 magdintag suspect,
15:30 or even both, nga magka mga
15:32 quotation, mga fananay,
15:34 we still presume
15:36 because you are a suspect, meaning
15:38 you are not judged still nga ikaw
15:40 nagyon na nagtrabaho. That's why we always
15:42 put kungan kanang suspect
15:44 allegedly. Pero kaya siya,
15:46 usan na siya doon. Ang ako sa
15:48 Col. Pilari is, kanang
15:50 drug bust,
15:52 kung nakuhaan na magyugad ito,
15:54 at least it's like a certain nagyapon
15:56 tangan, nakuhaan na magyugad ito. So,
15:58 unsa ikuhan sa police, at the
16:00 same time, kaya siya,
16:02 kanang, unsa pa,
16:04 you're caught
16:06 with a flagrante delecto,
16:08 pananginana, can we still not name their
16:10 names? Or how are we
16:12 gonna go about it? I understand, but that
16:14 is, kanang mangudya,
16:16 that is the version of the PNP.
16:18 That is the result of the investigation.
16:20 We have not yet
16:22 heard the version of the
16:24 suspect. So,
16:26 if you name them,
16:28 we know the repercussions,
16:30 sa iyang alan, sa iyang
16:32 family.
16:34 I'm not dealing anymore
16:36 with the policy because the policy
16:38 is very clear. There's no room for
16:40 interpretation. Ako alam, I'm
16:42 trying to explain, ganung inunaan na
16:44 ang policy sa PNP.
16:46 To my mind,
16:48 it's because of
16:50 our strict observance of
16:52 that right, constitutional
16:54 right, nga ipisyumang
16:56 unsa katawa na innocent until proven otherwise.
16:58 Labi na sa social media
17:00 age. Karo, once you are
17:02 named,
17:04 mukuyanap din
17:06 ang in the end,
17:08 the police
17:10 was not able to prove
17:12 culpability after
17:14 Kyle, then madalas
17:16 yung name. That is
17:18 ipisyum, the idea
17:20 on that policy,
17:22 why we are now
17:24 withholding the names of suspects and
17:26 victims. Not only suspects, but victims.
17:28 Di nila ba murag
17:30 na kanina part murag
17:32 nag-conflict ang freedom of
17:34 information, o ang data privacy.
17:36 Yes.
17:38 [Laughter]
17:40 There is a freedom of information
17:42 that allows us to get the right
17:44 information to...
17:46 Not just us, the public.
17:48 To push to the Kuan.
17:50 But there's also a data privacy.
17:52 We know that
17:54 all freedoms are not absolute.
17:56 Yes, of course.
17:58 Freedom
18:00 is always limited.
18:02 Because if freedom is absolute,
18:04 it will be very chaotic.
18:06 Like for example, freedom of expression,
18:08 but na apoy limitation.
18:10 It could be libelous at times.
18:12 Yes.
18:14 There is a freedom of
18:16 information
18:18 while the idea is
18:20 accessibility, we cannot
18:22 deny that there are information
18:24 that should be withheld.
18:26 There are also other policies
18:28 like for example, sub judice.
18:30 Yes, I understand that.
18:32 The moment you reach the court,
18:34 you are not allowed to
18:36 sue that case.
18:38 But if you can see,
18:40 sometimes the police
18:42 will really
18:44 accommodate. He will really try
18:46 to be accessible to the media
18:48 and even telling things that are
18:50 already under sub judice rule.
18:52 The point here is
18:54 that even though we have
18:56 certain freedoms,
18:58 there are corresponding
19:00 limitations that we also need to observe.
19:02 We are actually
19:04 legitimate media.
19:06 Legitimate.
19:08 We are very worried
19:10 because
19:12 instead of modernizing
19:14 the media,
19:16 we are distributing information
19:18 to our audience also.
19:20 We have our audience.
19:22 We are not going to
19:24 deteriorate because
19:26 we have our audience.
19:28 We have our audience here.
19:30 They are alarmed
19:32 that we are covering this.
19:34 We are not covering this.
19:36 As you have mentioned,
19:38 other than the names,
19:40 we can actually give you
19:42 details. How the crime
19:44 was committed,
19:46 when the crime was committed, where the crime
19:48 is committed. What we are just
19:50 withholding now are the identities
19:52 of the persons involved.
19:54 So it's clear now.
19:56 But where is the...
19:58 Oh, it's Col. Philarine.
20:00 [Laughs]
20:02 You?
20:04 She's the one who promoted you.
20:06 Let's say for example,
20:08 this recent case in the NBI
20:10 wherein
20:12 they will come out.
20:14 This illegal recruitment.
20:16 If they can't identify it,
20:18 they will be brought on
20:20 because they are the victims.
20:22 So it's actually a downside
20:24 if they are brought on.
20:26 Yes, we recognize that actually.
20:28 Actually, there are instances
20:30 that it is practical
20:32 for us to release names.
20:34 But
20:36 in aid of investigation.
20:38 However, also we need to balance
20:40 it with the existing policy.
20:42 For example, this one.
20:44 We talked about that case.
20:46 It's actually practical to release the names
20:48 so that other victims can report also.
20:50 Identify, yes.
20:52 The problem is, we are also
20:54 barred by major
20:56 policies of
20:58 observance of presumption of
21:00 innocence. That's why we really need to
21:02 balance.
21:04 The PNP,
21:06 as I have stated
21:08 when we started this interview,
21:10 the media will appreciate
21:12 the PNP's approach as a partner.
21:14 In fact, in Pro 7,
21:16 for example, we never had
21:18 a problem with the media.
21:20 That's the problem.
21:22 As far as the regulations
21:24 can allow, we will
21:26 really give in information.
21:28 It's just that there's now a policy
21:30 that limits this
21:32 particular accessibility.
21:34 Earlier, I was talking to
21:36 Mola and...
21:38 Cornell Tilare.
21:40 Sir, just sir.
21:42 One of the things I saw
21:44 in the stories,
21:46 the reporter asked, "What is this
21:48 that you mentioned?"
21:50 He said, "Investigator on case."
21:52 He said, "Investigator on case,
21:54 did you mention the person
21:56 who was the victim?"
21:58 The person who was the victim
22:00 was surprised.
22:02 Is that a SOP for you
22:04 if you gather
22:06 the information that you mentioned?
22:08 We already interviewed
22:10 the police officers who were
22:12 involved in the operation.
22:14 Some of them, of course,
22:16 except the names,
22:18 but they were not mentioned.
22:20 I saw the reporter
22:22 saying, "Hello, sir. I mentioned
22:24 the captain, the police chief."
22:26 He was not there.
22:28 For that,
22:30 I don't know.
22:32 He was authorized to release.
22:34 I asked, "Is that an SOP
22:36 for you as a PNP?"
22:38 On the operational side,
22:40 the chief of police
22:42 supervises every
22:44 police action.
22:46 There is no operation conducted
22:48 without the authority of the chief of police.
22:50 That's the reason why
22:52 I mentioned him
22:54 because although he was not there,
22:56 he is a part of the team.
22:58 He is accountable.
23:00 Yes, as the supervisor.
23:02 If there are
23:04 operational lapses here,
23:06 he is accountable for
23:08 command responsibility.
23:10 That's the reason why.
23:12 If there is a problem,
23:14 he is not the one to be blamed
23:16 for not being there or not being involved
23:18 in the operations because he is always
23:20 the head of the unit in all police operations.
23:22 Aside from the media accessibility,
23:24 the chief of police,
23:26 according to the policy,
23:28 it's only the chief of police
23:30 who can release information
23:32 or is designated
23:34 public information officer
23:36 or spokesperson.
23:38 Even the investigator,
23:40 if he is not authorized by the chief of police,
23:42 he cannot release information.
23:44 Yes.
23:46 We have observed that lately.
23:48 Actually, the reporters
23:50 who covered the case,
23:52 they were not at our desk.
23:54 They were at the other side
23:56 of the room.
23:58 They were not involved in the case.
24:00 When you interviewed them,
24:02 they did not quote the chief.
24:04 How can you say
24:06 that the police
24:08 quoted the chief
24:10 when he did not tell the story?
24:12 So that means the chief
24:14 is the one who interviewed.
24:16 If that's the case, that is a departure
24:18 of the procedure.
24:20 He cannot be interviewed
24:22 by the police but he will be
24:24 made to be the chief of police.
24:26 He cannot be included in the policy.
24:28 In that situation,
24:30 he cannot be called a direct quote.
24:32 Like you said,
24:34 the chief
24:36 who is making the information
24:38 is not allowed.
24:40 That's correct.
24:42 We get the information
24:44 except for the names.
24:46 We get the information
24:48 from him,
24:50 from the police officer.
24:52 But we cannot mention him
24:54 because he is still involved.
24:56 The chief is the only one
24:58 who can be mentioned.
25:00 Now, Colonel Pilare
25:02 is explaining that
25:04 this time,
25:06 with this policy,
25:08 the more the police
25:10 are involved,
25:12 the more accessible
25:14 to the media because they are
25:16 authorized to say what they want.
25:18 They are not authorized
25:20 although you can ask them
25:22 for information,
25:24 but officially, they cannot disclose.
25:26 You can call the hippies
25:28 of the police.
25:30 You have a lot of cellphones.
25:32 You can call them.
25:34 The chief of police cannot avoid it.
25:36 They should answer
25:38 media calls.
25:40 There are a lot of times in the past
25:42 that our arrangement
25:44 with the media,
25:46 the accredited,
25:48 if the chief of police will not respond,
25:50 they will coordinate with us
25:52 so that we can
25:54 give the chief of police an opportunity.
25:56 Of course, we should also consider
25:58 that the chief of police
26:00 is working there
26:02 because he has not yet answered
26:04 the media calls. He doesn't want
26:06 to talk to the media. Probably,
26:08 he was not invited
26:10 or was not at the conference
26:12 where he was not yet allowed to answer
26:14 or he is still conducting
26:16 investigation. He doesn't have
26:18 the details yet.
26:20 It's just a matter of
26:22 fostering
26:24 partnership on the ground.
26:26 We have seen this.
26:28 There are improvements.
26:30 The chief of police
26:32 are now responding.
26:34 If they are not available,
26:36 they will just honestly say, "Can you call
26:38 back an hour from now?"
26:40 Or if he can,
26:42 he will designate a public information
26:44 officer or a spokesperson
26:46 on his behalf.
26:48 We will talk about
26:50 this data privacy act.
26:52 Yes, I will
26:54 watch.
26:56 We will talk about
26:58 this data privacy act.
27:00 We will talk about
27:02 this data privacy act.
27:04 We will talk about
27:06 this data privacy act.
27:08 We will talk about
27:10 this data privacy act.
27:12 We will talk about
27:14 this data privacy act.
27:16 We will talk about
27:18 this data privacy act.
27:20 We will talk about
27:22 this data privacy act.
27:24 We will talk about
27:26 this data privacy act.
27:28 We will talk about
27:30 this data privacy act.
27:32 We will talk about
27:34 this data privacy act.
27:36 We will talk about
27:38 this data privacy act.
27:40 We will talk about
27:42 this data privacy act.
27:44 We will talk about
27:46 this data privacy act.
27:48 We will talk about
27:50 this data privacy act.
27:52 We will talk about
27:54 this data privacy act.
27:56 We will talk about
27:58 this data privacy act.
28:00 We will talk about
28:02 this data privacy act.
28:04 We will talk about
28:06 this data privacy act.
28:08 We will talk about
28:10 this data privacy act.
28:12 We will talk about
28:14 this data privacy act.
28:16 We will talk about
28:18 this data privacy act.
28:20 We will talk about
28:22 this data privacy act.
28:24 We will talk about
28:26 this data privacy act.
28:28 We will talk about
28:30 this data privacy act.
28:32 We will talk about
28:34 this data privacy act.
28:36 We will talk about
28:38 this data privacy act.
28:40 We will talk about
28:42 this data privacy act.
28:44 We will talk about
28:46 this data privacy act.
28:48 We will talk about
28:50 this data privacy act.
28:52 We will talk about
28:54 this data privacy act.
28:56 We will talk about
28:58 this data privacy act.
29:00 We will talk about
29:02 this data privacy act.
29:04 We will talk about
29:06 this data privacy act.
29:08 We will talk about
29:10 this data privacy act.
29:12 We will talk about
29:14 this data privacy act.
29:16 We will talk about
29:18 this data privacy act.
29:20 We will talk about
29:22 this data privacy act.
29:24 We will talk about
29:26 this data privacy act.
29:28 We will talk about
29:30 this data privacy act.
29:32 We will talk about
29:34 this data privacy act.
29:36 We will talk about
29:38 this data privacy act.
29:40 We will talk about
29:42 this data privacy act.
29:44 We will talk about
29:46 this data privacy act.
29:48 We will talk about
29:50 this data privacy act.
29:52 We will talk about
29:54 this data privacy act.
29:56 We will talk about
29:58 this data privacy act.
30:00 We will talk about
30:02 this data privacy act.
30:04 We will talk about
30:06 this data privacy act.
30:08 We will talk about
30:10 this data privacy act.
30:12 We will talk about
30:14 this data privacy act.
30:16 We will talk about
30:18 this data privacy act.
30:20 We will talk about
30:22 this data privacy act.
30:24 We will talk about
30:26 this data privacy act.
30:28 We will talk about
30:30 this data privacy act.
30:32 We will talk about
30:34 this data privacy act.
30:36 We will talk about
30:38 this data privacy act.
30:40 We will talk about
30:42 this data privacy act.
30:44 We will talk about
30:46 this data privacy act.
30:48 We will talk about
30:50 this data privacy act.
30:52 We will talk about
30:54 this data privacy act.
30:56 We will talk about
30:58 this data privacy act.
31:00 We will talk about
31:02 this data privacy act.
31:04 We will talk about
31:06 this data privacy act.
31:08 We will talk about
31:10 this data privacy act.
31:12 We will talk about
31:14 this data privacy act.
31:16 We will talk about
31:18 this data privacy act.
31:20 We will talk about
31:22 this data privacy act.
31:24 We will talk about
31:26 this data privacy act.
31:28 We will talk about
31:30 this data privacy act.
31:32 We will talk about
31:34 this data privacy act.
31:36 We will talk about
31:38 this data privacy act.
31:40 We will talk about
31:42 this data privacy act.
31:44 We will talk about
31:46 this data privacy act.
31:48 We will talk about
31:50 this data privacy act.
31:52 We will talk about
31:54 this data privacy act.
31:56 We will talk about
31:58 this data privacy act.
32:00 We will talk about
32:02 this data privacy act.
32:04 We will talk about
32:06 this data privacy act.
32:08 We will talk about
32:10 this data privacy act.
32:12 We will talk about
32:14 this data privacy act.
32:16 We will talk about
32:18 this data privacy act.
32:20 We will talk about
32:22 this data privacy act.
32:24 We will talk about
32:26 this data privacy act.
32:28 We will talk about
32:30 this data privacy act.
32:32 We will talk about
32:34 this data privacy act.
32:36 We will talk about
32:38 this data privacy act.
32:40 We will talk about
32:42 this data privacy act.
32:44 We will talk about
32:46 this data privacy act.
32:48 We will talk about
32:50 this data privacy act.
32:52 We will talk about
32:54 this data privacy act.
32:56 We will talk about
32:58 this data privacy act.
33:00 We will talk about
33:02 this data privacy act.
33:04 We will talk about
33:06 this data privacy act.
33:08 We will talk about
33:10 this data privacy act.
33:12 We will talk about
33:14 this data privacy act.
33:16 We will talk about
33:18 this data privacy act.
33:20 We will talk about
33:22 this data privacy act.
33:24 We will talk about
33:26 this data privacy act.
33:28 We will talk about
33:30 this data privacy act.
33:32 We will talk about
33:34 this data privacy act.
33:36 We will talk about
33:38 this data privacy act.
33:40 We will talk about
33:42 this data privacy act.
33:44 We will talk about
33:46 this data privacy act.
33:48 We will talk about
33:50 this data privacy act.
33:52 We will talk about
33:54 this data privacy act.
33:56 We will talk about
33:58 this data privacy act.
34:00 We will talk about
34:02 this data privacy act.
34:04 We will talk about
34:06 this data privacy act.
34:08 We will talk about
34:10 this data privacy act.
34:12 We will talk about
34:14 this data privacy act.
34:16 We will talk about
34:18 this data privacy act.
34:20 We will talk about
34:22 this data privacy act.
34:24 We will talk about
34:26 this data privacy act.
34:28 We will talk about
34:30 this data privacy act.
34:32 We will talk about
34:34 this data privacy act.
34:36 We will talk about
34:38 this data privacy act.
34:40 We will talk about
34:42 this data privacy act.
34:44 We will talk about
34:46 this data privacy act.
34:48 We will talk about
34:50 this data privacy act.
34:52 We will talk about
34:54 this data privacy act.
34:56 We will talk about
34:58 this data privacy act.
35:00 We will talk about
35:02 this data privacy act.
35:04 We will talk about
35:06 this data privacy act.
35:08 We will talk about
35:10 this data privacy act.
35:12 We will talk about
35:14 this data privacy act.
35:16 We will talk about
35:18 this data privacy act.
35:20 We will talk about
35:22 this data privacy act.
35:24 We will talk about
35:26 this data privacy act.
35:28 We will talk about
35:30 this data privacy act.
35:32 We will talk about
35:34 this data privacy act.
35:36 We will talk about
35:38 this data privacy act.
35:40 We will talk about
35:42 this data privacy act.
35:44 We will talk about
35:46 this data privacy act.
35:48 We will talk about
35:50 this data privacy act.
35:52 We will talk about
35:54 this data privacy act.
35:56 We will talk about
35:58 this data privacy act.
36:00 We will talk about
36:02 this data privacy act.
36:04 We will talk about
36:06 this data privacy act.
36:08 We will talk about
36:10 this data privacy act.
36:12 We will talk about
36:14 this data privacy act.
36:16 We will talk about
36:18 this data privacy act.
36:20 We will talk about
36:22 this data privacy act.
36:24 We will talk about
36:26 this data privacy act.
36:28 We will talk about
36:30 this data privacy act.
36:32 We will talk about
36:34 this data privacy act.
36:36 We will talk about
36:38 this data privacy act.
36:40 We will talk about
36:42 this data privacy act.
36:44 We will talk about
36:46 this data privacy act.
36:48 We will talk about
36:50 this data privacy act.
36:52 We will talk about
36:54 this data privacy act.
36:56 We will talk about
36:58 this data privacy act.
37:00 We will talk about
37:02 this data privacy act.
37:04 We will talk about
37:06 this data privacy act.
37:08 We will talk about
37:10 this data privacy act.
37:12 We will talk about
37:14 this data privacy act.
37:16 We will talk about
37:18 this data privacy act.
37:20 We will talk about
37:22 this data privacy act.
37:24 We will talk about
37:26 this data privacy act.
37:28 We will talk about
37:30 this data privacy act.
37:32 We will talk about
37:34 this data privacy act.
37:36 We will talk about
37:38 this data privacy act.
37:40 We will talk about
37:42 this data privacy act.
37:44 We will talk about
37:46 this data privacy act.
37:48 We will talk about
37:50 this data privacy act.
37:52 We will talk about
37:54 this data privacy act.
37:56 We will talk about
37:58 this data privacy act.
38:00 We will talk about
38:02 this data privacy act.
38:04 We will talk about
38:06 this data privacy act.
38:08 We will talk about
38:10 this data privacy act.
38:12 We will talk about
38:14 this data privacy act.
38:16 We will talk about
38:18 this data privacy act.
38:20 We will talk about
38:22 this data privacy act.
38:24 We will talk about
38:26 this data privacy act.
38:28 We will talk about
38:30 this data privacy act.
38:32 We will talk about
38:34 this data privacy act.
38:36 We will talk about
38:38 this data privacy act.
38:40 We will talk about
38:42 this data privacy act.
38:44 We will talk about
38:46 this data privacy act.
38:48 We will talk about
38:50 this data privacy act.
38:52 We will talk about
38:54 this data privacy act.
38:56 We will talk about
38:58 this data privacy act.
39:00 We will talk about
39:02 this data privacy act.
39:04 We will talk about
39:06 this data privacy act.
39:08 We will talk about
39:10 this data privacy act.
39:12 We will talk about
39:14 this data privacy act.
39:16 We will talk about
39:18 this data privacy act.
39:20 We will talk about
39:22 this data privacy act.
39:24 By the way, before we proceed,
39:26 I want to mention
39:28 Mildred Galarpie and
39:30 Ludwig Kim.
39:32 Ludwig is watching.
39:34 Of course, Nondong.
39:36 They are here.
39:38 They are here.
39:40 We will go back.
39:42 We will interview the barangay councilor.
39:44 We will interview the barangay councilor.
39:46 We will ask the entire
39:48 barangay officials to come
39:50 to Ombudsman to allow
39:52 to come back after the issue of
39:54 cease and desist order of the mayor.
39:56 They will allow to come back
39:58 to operate the shipwrecking
40:00 to operate the shipwrecking
40:02 in this area.
40:04 This is what we will clarify
40:06 in Ombudsman.
40:08 Before that, we will listen to
40:10 energy conservation tips
40:12 from Visayan Electric.
40:14 [Music]
40:16 [Music]
40:18 [Music]
40:20 (upbeat music)
40:23 (upbeat music)
40:25 (upbeat music)
40:28 (upbeat music)
40:51 (upbeat music)
40:53 (upbeat music)
40:56 (upbeat music)
41:07 (upbeat music)
41:17 (upbeat music)
41:19 (upbeat music)
41:41 (upbeat music)
41:43 (upbeat music)
41:46 (upbeat music)
41:48 (upbeat music)
41:51 (upbeat music)
41:53 - Okay, we're back now.
42:20 (speaking in foreign language)
42:24 (laughing)
42:26 (speaking in foreign language)
42:31 - Yes, in relation to that,
42:43 (speaking in foreign language)
42:47 - Of course, (speaking in foreign language)
42:52 (speaking in foreign language)
42:55 - Anyway, (speaking in foreign language)
43:00 (speaking in foreign language)
43:11 (laughing)
43:15 (speaking in foreign language)
43:19 (speaking in foreign language)
43:24 (speaking in foreign language)
43:28 (speaking in foreign language)
43:32 - Okay.
43:36 (speaking in foreign language)
43:40 (speaking in foreign language)
43:44 (speaking in foreign language)
43:48 (speaking in foreign language)
43:52 (speaking in foreign language)
43:56 (speaking in foreign language)
44:22 - By the way, councillor,
44:24 before I proceed to some questions,
44:27 (speaking in foreign language)
44:31 but before that,
44:38 (speaking in foreign language)
44:41 - Skin diseases, respiratory problems.
44:50 (speaking in foreign language)
44:54 (speaking in foreign language)
44:58 (speaking in foreign language)
45:02 - Did they follow the cease and desist order?
45:25 (speaking in foreign language)
45:29 (speaking in foreign language)
45:33 (speaking in foreign language)
45:37 (speaking in foreign language)
45:41 (speaking in foreign language)
45:45 (speaking in foreign language)
46:09 (speaking in foreign language)
46:13 (speaking in foreign language)
46:30 - That's a permit.
46:32 (speaking in foreign language)
46:36 - We have the power to lift the cease and desist order
46:37 only the city mayor.
46:39 (speaking in foreign language)
46:43 (speaking in foreign language)
46:47 (speaking in foreign language)
46:51 (speaking in foreign language)
46:55 (speaking in foreign language)
46:59 (speaking in foreign language)
47:03 (speaking in foreign language)
47:11 (speaking in foreign language)
47:25 - Permit, three days after the cease and desist order,
47:28 (speaking in foreign language)
47:31 So no, the resolution--
47:33 (speaking in foreign language)
47:34 - Yes, uh-huh.
47:35 (speaking in foreign language)
47:39 - Cutting out the--
47:51 (speaking in foreign language)
47:55 (speaking in foreign language)
48:00 - Okay.
48:01 (speaking in foreign language)
48:27 (speaking in foreign language)
48:31 (speaking in foreign language)
48:35 (speaking in foreign language)
48:40 (speaking in foreign language)
48:44 (speaking in foreign language)
48:48 (speaking in foreign language)
48:52 (speaking in foreign language)
48:56 (speaking in foreign language)
49:00 (speaking in foreign language)
49:04 - Sir, will it by effect to your marine environment
49:29 (speaking in foreign language)
49:33 (speaking in foreign language)
49:58 (speaking in foreign language)
50:02 (speaking in foreign language)
50:06 (speaking in foreign language)
50:10 (speaking in foreign language)
50:30 (speaking in foreign language)
50:34 (speaking in foreign language)
50:38 (speaking in foreign language)
50:43 (speaking in foreign language)
50:48 (speaking in foreign language)
50:52 (speaking in foreign language)
51:20 (speaking in foreign language)
51:24 (speaking in foreign language)
51:28 (speaking in foreign language)
51:32 (speaking in foreign language)
51:38 (speaking in foreign language)
51:42 (speaking in foreign language)
52:00 (speaking in foreign language)
52:04 (speaking in foreign language)
52:27 (speaking in foreign language)
52:31 - So anyway, (speaking in foreign language)
52:45 (speaking in foreign language)
52:51 (speaking in foreign language)
52:54 (speaking in foreign language)
53:14 (speaking in foreign language)
53:18 (speaking in foreign language)
53:29 (speaking in foreign language)
53:39 (speaking in foreign language)
53:43 (speaking in foreign language)
53:55 (speaking in foreign language)
53:59 (speaking in foreign language)
54:21 (speaking in foreign language)
54:25 (speaking in foreign language)
54:30 (speaking in foreign language)
54:48 (speaking in foreign language)
55:15 - A viewing from MCPO PS4, Sigrat Dili Dili.
55:20 (speaking in foreign language)
55:25 City Mobile Force Company, MCPO,
55:39 thank you for watching.
55:40 (speaking in foreign language)
55:43 From the headquarters of MCPO.
55:45 (speaking in foreign language)
55:49 Watching from Beverly Hills, shout out me,
55:56 Noel O'Marley.
55:58 (speaking in foreign language)
56:10 (speaking in foreign language)
56:14 (speaking in foreign language)
56:20 (speaking in foreign language)
56:38 (speaking in foreign language)
56:42 Shout out me, please, watching from
56:46 Punta Inganyo, Barangay Hall.
56:48 (speaking in foreign language)
57:06 Environmental fees.
57:08 (speaking in foreign language)
57:12 (speaking in foreign language)
57:34 Watching from Abu Dhabi, UAE.
57:36 (speaking in foreign language)
57:40 (speaking in foreign language)
57:44 (speaking in foreign language)
57:48 (speaking in foreign language)
57:52 (speaking in foreign language)
57:56 CMS Consumers.
57:58 Hi, sir, Moralio.
58:00 (speaking in foreign language)
58:04 (speaking in foreign language)
58:07 (speaking in foreign language)
58:11 Shout out.
58:26 We're open even birthdays.
58:28 (speaking in foreign language)
58:32 (speaking in foreign language)
58:37 Anyway, so.
58:38 (speaking in foreign language)
58:42 (speaking in foreign language)
58:46 (speaking in foreign language)
58:51 Beyond the Headlines.
58:52 (speaking in foreign language)
58:56 (speaking in foreign language)
59:00 (speaking in foreign language)
59:04 (speaking in foreign language)
59:08 (speaking in foreign language)
59:12 (speaking in foreign language)
59:16 (speaking in foreign language)
59:20 (speaking in foreign language)
59:25 (speaking in foreign language)
59:30 (speaking in foreign language)
59:34 (speaks in foreign language)