A week after Prime Minister Modi said the Opposition was not debating the actual contents of the farm bills, MP Deepender Singh Hooda addressed some of the more technical aspects...
Category
🗞
NewsTranscript
00:00And I saw that in this discussion, no one discussed the spirit of the law.
00:06Complaints were given that the method was not right, it was done in a hurry, it was not asked, this is Rata.
00:11There was a lot of discussion on the agricultural law.
00:14It was said that talk about the movement, what is black in these laws, we were not told.
00:19I want to tell two or three things in that too, what is black.
00:30You said a farmers' assembly has delivered 11 rounds of discussion and did not tell anything black, is the difference of view.
00:41Take this, now go to the new law and talk about Indian law based on this report.
00:46We have made changes that are based on this report as well, is what is mentioned in the new law.
01:24We have not come to the path of struggle and movement.
01:27If the child law is implemented, the children in Delhi will not be forced to give back the child law.
01:32If the dowry law is implemented, the women will not be forced to give dowry.
01:36But the work that you have given here, that work has come to your door today.
01:40It is sitting around Delhi in the number of lakhs.
01:43You said that the mandi is not over.
01:46It is true.
01:48There is no plan to end the mandi.
01:50Two mandis have been made.
01:52One is a PG mandi in which tax will not be imposed.
01:55And the other is a government mandi in which tax is imposed.
01:57Two mandis.
01:58One country, one constitution.
02:00One country, one constitution.
02:02One country, one symbol.
02:03One country, one election.
02:04One country, one market.
02:06So, one country, two mandis. Why?
02:08Why did you get only farmers?
02:10One mandi.
02:11And you are saying that tax has been released.
02:13Who pays tax?
02:14The buyer pays tax in these mandis.
02:16The farmer does not pay.
02:17Punjab pays 6.5%, Haryana pays 4%.
02:20And the government pays.
02:21Why is the rural infrastructure of Haryana and Punjab good today?
02:24Why are there good roads in every village?
02:26Because the tax that goes to the rural infrastructure
02:29and for the development of these mandis and farmers,
02:31this tax is used.
02:33That is why today Punjab and Haryana are at the forefront.
02:35Then it came that MSP is over.
02:38The Prime Minister said that MSP was there and will remain.
02:41Mr. Thakur also said that there is no one who can say that MSP will go away.
02:46It is true that MSP was there and will remain.
02:48But will MSP be available to all farmers and to all crops?
02:52The question arises.
02:54Do you have the strength to say that MSP will be available to every farmer in the country?
02:58Even today, the Shanta Kumar Committee says that
03:01only 6% to 16% of farmers get MSP.
03:04There are many other states in the country where MSP is not available.
03:08What you wanted was that
03:10MSP is available in Punjab, Haryana, West Uttar Pradesh.
03:13The same MSP is available in Bihar,
03:15and the same MSP is available in Punjab, Haryana, West Uttar Pradesh.
03:19You should have taken MSP to those states.
03:22But instead of taking MSP to the farmers of Haryana and Punjab,
03:27you should have taken MSP to the farmers of Haryana and Punjab.
03:31You are talking about privatization.
03:34You are not privatizing.
03:36The private sector came, but who stopped the private sector from coming to the mandis?
03:39The private sector came to the mandis and bought more than MSP.
03:42They are saying that you will get more price outside.
03:45There will be an exchange.
03:47You will get more price outside.
03:49Why do you have a problem in making this law?
03:52If there is a contract less than MSP,
03:55then it will be legal.
03:57In Haryana, in 2007,
03:59we brought a contract amendment in APMC.
04:02We allowed private companies.
04:04But we also wrote a law
04:06that if the contract is lower than MSP,
04:09then it will be illegal.
04:11And there will be legal proceedings.
04:14You are saying that if you get more, then you should do it.
04:17You should do the legal work.