Visit our website:
http://www.france24.com
Like us on Facebook:
https://www.facebook.com/FRANCE24.English
Follow us on Twitter:
https://twitter.com/France24_en
Category
🗞
NewsTranscript
00:00Though the Kremlin has yet again to officially respond to that Washington-led 30-day ceasefire
00:05proposal, Vladimir Putin's top foreign policy aide said Thursday that that deal, at least
00:09as it stands, would simply give Ukrainian troops a break.
00:13Those comments then suggesting that optimism from the White House about Russia agreeing
00:17to that proposal could perhaps be premature.
00:21For more, we're going to speak now to Peter Zalmayev, director of the Eurasia Democracy
00:25Initiative.
00:26Peter, thank you very much for joining us today.
00:28So I want to start by asking you, you know, for a war that's been going on for three years
00:33already, a 30-day ceasefire doesn't really seem like it's particularly significant.
00:38So with such a short timeline, what purpose would this serve, even if both sides do agree
00:43to it?
00:44Well, I think the one side is very interested in the ceasefire, apart from the warring parties
00:51and the idea that, you know, civilians must stop to suffer in this war.
00:58If the Trump administration, the Trump administration is hurrying to be able to claim that it was
01:05able to achieve a certain peace in Ukraine within the 100 days of Donald Trump's presidency.
01:10So the haste sort of dictates the schedule.
01:15Both sides are wary that the other side will take greater advantage of the ceasefire.
01:21Russians are claiming Ukraine will be able to build its air defenses and entrench in
01:29the current front lines.
01:31Ukraine believes that Russia may take greater advantage of it.
01:34The jury is still out on that.
01:36But one thing is clear, Vladimir Putin does believe that he has the upper hand in this.
01:43He's got the upper hand in the Kursk region, and that is the one bargaining sort of chip
01:47that Ukraine wanted to have going into these negotiations.
01:51And if Russia is able to kick the Ukrainians out of its territory, it will have a stronger
01:57hand.
01:58So this is where we're at.
01:59And once again, you know, coming back to the idea that Russians, sorry, Americans and Ukrainians
02:06have proposed to Russia this 30-day deal, ceasefire, Vladimir Putin has to walk a very
02:12tight sort of rope.
02:16It cannot appear to be a warmongering party, while at the same time, Vladimir Putin clearly
02:22is not interested in stopping the war on any terms other than Ukraine's complete capitulation.
02:29So do you think it's realistic, then, that Washington, you know, and given that Donald
02:34Trump is in the White House, that there would be any consequences for Russia if it were
02:39to refuse to accept this 30-day proposal, or if it were to continue the war even after
02:43a potential 30-day ceasefire?
02:46I believe Donald Trump would be hard-pressed not to.
02:49Once again, Donald Trump has been saying very many things, and many of them very friendly,
02:54suspiciously friendly to Vladimir Putin, and is starting, I suspect, to coerce him politically.
03:00We saw the front page of the New York Post, the normally very Trump-friendly outlet owned
03:05by Rupert Murdoch, where it had to remind Donald Trump it's not Zelensky who is the
03:11dictator, but Vladimir Putin who is the real dictator.
03:14So we've seen this sort of tendency.
03:17Donald Trump will be hard-pressed not to put his money where his mouth is and hurt Russia,
03:24levy additional sanctions to Russia, because don't forget, that was his initial campaign
03:29promise, you know.
03:30So that's where we are.
03:32You mentioned very briefly earlier about, you know, Russia thinking that time is on
03:36its side.
03:37I want to ask you about the Ukrainian perspective of things.
03:41Of course, this war has been going on for three years.
03:44Is there a generalized sense of war fatigue?
03:47Do you think that there's a population of Ukrainians that are ready for the war to end,
03:51no matter the conditions?
03:54I wouldn't say no matter the conditions.
03:56We're still talking about a significant majority of Ukrainians, not the same as before, obviously,
04:01but way over 50 percent that do not, would not accept capitulation of Ukraine.
04:07But yes, having said that, Ukrainians are fatigued.
04:10Don't forget, every day we are facing shellings by Russians.
04:15We've lived through hundreds, if not thousands, of air raid sirens since the start of this
04:20war.
04:21It's simply inhuman, what Ukrainians have gone through.
04:24And yes, they want to see an end to this war, but once again, not at the expense of
04:31its very existence.
04:33Among Russia's demands, Peter, have been Ukraine never joining NATO alongside an agreement
04:39that no foreign troops ever be present on Ukrainian territory.
04:42But the rhetoric that we have heard from both the EU and NATO leaders in recent days suggests
04:47that they still expect both of these things to be possible.
04:50I mean, they talk about these things happening once a ceasefire deal is reached.
04:55Russia's been clear that that's not acceptable in its view.
04:58So do you think that Europeans will or should compromise on either of those points?
05:04I think Europeans will do eventually what Washington decides.
05:11I'm afraid we still, it's still premature to talk about, you know, Europe finally having
05:17woken up, not just to the reality of Russia's threat, but what it will take to credibly
05:23meet this threat and to provide Ukraine with ironclad security guarantees.
05:29It's just not there militarily.
05:31Its military-industrial complex, unfortunately, is not there.
05:35What Europe can and should do is actually finally decide the fate of the $300 billion
05:42of Russian sovereign wealth fund that's been frozen largely in European banks.
05:48That is something that probably the White House would welcome.
05:52That money should start working now to help Ukraine defend itself and eventually to help
05:57Ukraine rebuild itself.
06:01The big debate about how to approach Vladimir Putin is whether or not he responds to more
06:06forceful action or more kind of diplomatic compromise, given what you just said about,
06:10you know, Europeans should be using this money to continue the war on the battlefield.
06:14I mean, which of these approaches to Vladimir Putin do you think is likely to work best,
06:19given where things stand now?
06:21Yeah, it's been said that Vladimir Putin understands the language of force.
06:25But once again, whatever language he's heard, I mean, it's been a language of force.
06:28You can say that it's not been forceful enough.
06:31The Biden administration had that formula of not letting Ukraine lose, but at the same
06:37time not letting Russia lose too badly either.
06:41Be it as it may, Vladimir Putin has staked his whole existence, his biological existence,
06:47his life as a politician, the fate of Russia, to the outcome of the war in Ukraine.
06:53Unfortunately, there's just no, you know, sort of magic wand that you can use to think
06:58of a solution or a decision.
07:01You have to continue supporting Ukraine.
07:03Ukraine has to continue to resist simply because it's not just the outcome of the war in Ukraine
07:11and the fate of Ukraine.
07:12It's the fate of the entire world and the precedent that a failure of the free world
07:18to defend Ukraine will set for the rest of the world.
07:23As a final question for you, Peter, do you think that there's anything that Western powers
07:29could have done differently over the past couple of decades that could have made the
07:33war that we see playing out now less likely?
07:36You know, I will just take you back to 2008 and the Bucharest summit where both Georgia
07:45and Ukraine were promised in kind of vague, nebulous terms, eventual membership in NATO.
07:50And the architect of that was Angela Merkel.
07:53And so that membership was dangled over Ukraine.
07:56It was never really a possibility in the near future.
08:00And at the same time, it really poked the Russian bear in the ribs.
08:04It teased the Russian bear.
08:06So Ukraine was left in this very unenviable, the worst situation possible, where it was
08:11promised this membership, Russia was irritated and angry, and at the same time, it was made
08:17clear that it's not going to happen in the next generation or two.
08:21So this is where we are, very short-sighted policy of the Western leaders who underestimated
08:27how belligerent, militaristic, revanchist Russia would be within a very short period
08:32of time.
08:33Peter Zalmayev, director of the Eurasia Democracy Initiative, thank you so much for coming on
08:38the show today.
08:39That's unfortunately all we have time for.