#Khabar #ImranKhan #PTI #ReservedSeats #ElectionCommission #SupremeCourt #QaziFeazIsa #JusticeMansoorAliShah #JusticeAtharMinallah #muneebfarooq #mariamemon #atherkazmi
What will the government do following the court's decision on reserved seats? Ather Kazmi's Analysis
What will the government do following the court's decision on reserved seats? Ather Kazmi's Analysis
Category
🗞
NewsTranscript
00:00The government has said that they will not accept the decision.
00:03It means that they will go for a review.
00:05The legal experts have said that 99% of the reviews do not have a different result.
00:10So the government does not have a chance to get a legal relief from there.
00:14We do not know if there will be some magic or some other miracle.
00:17So this means that the decision will not be implemented.
00:20And the court and the judge will be in front of each other.
00:24So the crisis will keep increasing.
00:27Look, there is no other option.
00:30Either they accept a review petition tonight or tomorrow.
00:33And the same bench will approve their decision.
00:36Otherwise, you have to implement it in any case.
00:40If you do not implement it, then there is no impact.
00:43If you do not implement it, then you have basically abrogated the law of Pakistan.
00:48And people are saying that we are going towards a legal crisis.
00:52The legal crisis started in this country when you did not have elections on the 9th.
00:57When you did not implement the things that were supposed to be implemented.
01:02Now, where are we going?
01:04Look, you also mentioned the committee.
01:06Today, Mansoor Ali Shah did not sit in it.
01:09If he did not sit in it, then the bench that was made,
01:12under which law was that bench made?
01:14The committee says that three people sat in it.
01:16In the same law, the majority of the decision was made,
01:18that is, two people formed the bench.
01:20Because after the ordinance, it is the law of the land.
01:23But the majority will be in it when all three are sitting.
01:26Because the day Qazi Faiz Isa Sahib did not come,
01:28the other two judges were waiting for the committee.
01:31And then the committee could not move forward.
01:34Now, if a third judge has not sat in it,
01:36he says that I am not a part of this committee.
01:38So, the rules are that the majority of two out of three will be accepted.
01:42Now, it is possible that the next step will be that the bench that has been made,
01:46in that, the respected judge,
01:48some judge should say that because all three members were not in the committee,
01:52therefore, this bench is not constitutional.
01:54So, there are chances of the bench breaking?
01:56There are clear chances of the bench breaking.
01:58I had also said that the new committee that is being made,
02:01it is possible that Mansoor Ali Shah does not sit in it.
02:04And then, with all the coordination, Muneeb Sahib also mentioned,
02:08that the ordinance had not even cooled down,
02:10that the committee was also not formed,
02:12Muneeb Sahib was also removed from there,
02:14the bench was also made, the case of 63A was also filed.
02:17So, all these things that people are seeing,
02:20obviously, people will comment on it,
02:22but coming back to this decision,
02:24whatever this decision is,
02:26either you have to run this country according to the constitution,
02:28anyone has power in this country.
02:30So, that constitution gives it power.
02:32It is on any position.
02:33When you start breaking the constitution,
02:35then no one has any power.
02:37Then things are free for all.
02:38So, Muneeb, if we do not implement this decision,
02:41I have seen that in the 90 days,
02:43the decision was not implemented in KP and Punjab.
02:46Today, we are standing here,
02:48but this is like setting a new precedent there.
02:52That after today,
02:53if there is a decision of the session court,
02:55a decision of the high court,
02:57a decision of the lower court,
02:59a decision of the supreme court,
03:01if it is not accepted,
03:03then tomorrow,
03:04everyone who has a pressure group,
03:06who has a little power,
03:07will not accept that decision.
03:09So, is this a new pact?
03:13Is this a new playbook?
03:15Let's try to reconnect Muneeb again.
03:17Take him on the telephone.
03:19So, if no one will accept the decision,
03:21then everyone will have a hand.
03:23You have the power,
03:24you have the power,
03:25you do not accept the decision.
03:26So, we have started a new struggle.
03:28Obviously,
03:29the way we are going,
03:31to be honest,
03:32no good news will come from there.
03:34Because today,
03:35if you are not accepting the decision of the supreme court,
03:37then tomorrow,
03:38some other government will not accept the decision of some other court.
03:40Some group,
03:41as you mentioned,
03:42will not accept the decision of the magistrate.
03:44So, you are going towards complete anarchy.
03:46The problem at this time,
03:47is not the consensus of Tehreek-e-Insaf,
03:49or the consensus of Noon League,
03:50or the consensus of the government.
03:52At this time,
03:53your constitution,
03:54your rule of law,
03:55and the form of the state in front of us,
03:57this is a struggle for its survival.
03:59If you bring the state in such a way,
04:01that where no one is being accepted,
04:03no one is accepting the constitution,
04:05then you can guess where we are going.
04:08But Atar,
04:09this country has taken the burden of the Supreme Court's decision
04:11to hang the Prime Minister.
04:13After 40 years,
04:14we are correcting those decisions today,
04:16but the one who was hanged,
04:17the one whose political revenge you took at that time,
04:19you took it.
04:20With this complicated history,
04:22should every decision be feasible,
04:24considering our political history?
04:26Look,
04:27it depends on the decision.
04:28There can be many such decisions,
04:30on which you object,
04:31I object.
04:32But this decision,
04:33on this occasion,
04:34the people who are presenting such explanations,
04:36basically,
04:37the friends of the government,
04:38that this is this, that is that,
04:39or they can say,
04:40that the government will like the decision,
04:43the parliament will like it,
04:44only that decision will be approved.
04:46And the decision that was made,
04:48in the era of Bhutto,
04:50sorry,
04:51the decision of Bhutto's death,
04:53was there a constitution in the country at that time?
04:55At that time,
04:56there was martial law in the country.
04:57How do they quote,
04:58that in the era of Amar,
05:00the courts,
05:01which were under the PCO,
05:02and the way there was pressure on them,
05:04in a democratic era,
05:05when two big democratic parties,
05:07who claim that we are big democratic parties,
05:09that is their government,
05:11in their era,
05:12the Supreme Court,
05:13which is making a decision,
05:14there was no action on it.
05:15And this idea of mutual consideration,
05:17this was about 3-4 judges,
05:19Mansoor Ali Shah,
05:20when did we become considerate?
05:21When did we become considerate?
05:22Yaya Afridi,
05:23when did we become considerate?
05:24The day the decision of the famous judges was made,
05:26from that day.
05:27Yaya Afridi,
05:28has written a controversial note,
05:29let's put him in the committee.
05:30The problem is that,
05:31you have put everything on one side,
05:33that sir,
05:34whatever happens,
05:35from whom we get that decision,
05:37which is acceptable for the government,
05:39it is a very unfortunate situation.
05:41We will see this in the fire-fighting mode,
05:43in the coming times,
05:44it means that,
05:45the future of these 25 special judges,
05:49will remain in the air.
05:51So Muneeb,
05:52after this,
05:53the government will not accept the decision,
05:55what options does the Supreme Court have?
05:57Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
05:59Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
06:00Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
06:01Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
06:02Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
06:03Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
06:04Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
06:05Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
06:06Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
06:07Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
06:08Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
06:09Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
06:10Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
06:11Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
06:12Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
06:13Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
06:14Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
06:15Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
06:16Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
06:17Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
06:18Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
06:19Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
06:20Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
06:21Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
06:22Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
06:23Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
06:24Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
06:25Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
06:26Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
06:27Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
06:28Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
06:29Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
06:30Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
06:31Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
06:32Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
06:33Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
06:34Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
06:35Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
06:36Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
06:37Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
06:38Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
06:39Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
06:40Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
06:41Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
06:42Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
06:43Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
06:44Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
06:45Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
06:46Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
06:47Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
06:48Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
06:49Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
06:50Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
06:51Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
06:52Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
06:53Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
06:54Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
06:55Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
06:56Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
06:57Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
06:58Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
06:59Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
07:00Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
07:01Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
07:02Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
07:03Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
07:04Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
07:05Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
07:06Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
07:07Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
07:08Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
07:09Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
07:10Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
07:11Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
07:12Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
07:13Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
07:14Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
07:15Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
07:16Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
07:17Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
07:18Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
07:19Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
07:20Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
07:21Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
07:22Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
07:23Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
07:24Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
07:25Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
07:26Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
07:27Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
07:28Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
07:29Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
07:30Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
07:31Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
07:32Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
07:33Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
07:34Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
07:35Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
07:36Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
07:37Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
07:38Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
07:39Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
07:40Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
07:41Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
07:42Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
07:43Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
07:44Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
07:45Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
07:46Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
07:47Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
07:48Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
07:49Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
07:50Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
07:51Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
07:52Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
07:53Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
07:54Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
07:55Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
07:56Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
07:57Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
07:58Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
07:59Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
08:00Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
08:01Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
08:02Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
08:03Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
08:04Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
08:05Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
08:06Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
08:07Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
08:08Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
08:09Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
08:10Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
08:11Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
08:12Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
08:13Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
08:14Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
08:15Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
08:16Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
08:17Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
08:18Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
08:19Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
08:20Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
08:21Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
08:22Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
08:23Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
08:24Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
08:25Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
08:26Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
08:27Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
08:28Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
08:29Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
08:30Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
08:31Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
08:33Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
08:34Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
08:35Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
08:36Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
08:37Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
08:38Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
08:39Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
08:40Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
08:41Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
08:42Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
08:43Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
08:44Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
08:45Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
08:46Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
08:47Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
08:48Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
08:49Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
08:50Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
08:51Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
08:52Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
08:53Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
08:54Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
08:55Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
08:56Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
08:57Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
08:58Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
08:59Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
09:00Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
09:01Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
09:02Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
09:03Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
09:04Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
09:05Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
09:06Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
09:07Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
09:08Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
09:09Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
09:10Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
09:11Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
09:12Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
09:13Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
09:14Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
09:15Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
09:16Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
09:17Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
09:18Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
09:19Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
09:20Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
09:21Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
09:22Can you send a notice of insult to the court?
09:23Can you send a notice of insult to the court?